Stop Judging Your Past Self | Still Stuck Part 2

You have done the therapy. Read the books. Learned about your nervous system. Maybe you can finally see your people-pleasing, perfectionist, and codependent patterns for what they are.

And now you cannot believe you used to behave that way.

Why did I stay so long?

Why did I say yes when I wanted to say no?

Why did I let people treat me that way?

Why didn’t I know better?

When we start growing, it can be tempting to look back at our past self with judgment. We see everything differently now, so surely we should have known then what we know today.

But judging your past self does not accelerate your growth.

It can actually keep you stuck.

Real change does not come from rejecting the person you used to be. It comes from understanding why that version of you developed those patterns in the first place and meeting them with compassion, curiosity, and care.

WATCH THE FULL EPISODE ON YOUTUBE HERE

Why We Judge Our Past Self

When you learn a new way of relating to yourself, it is easy to forget something important.

You just learned it.

We can be incredibly mean to ourselves for not knowing something before we knew it.

Perfectionist thinking tells us we should have somehow known all the things all along. Codependent thinking can tell us that if we were worthy, smart, or good enough, we would have made better choices.

So instead of celebrating how much we have learned, we focus on everything we believe we did wrong.

We think about the relationship we stayed in.

The boundary we did not set.

The job we accepted.

The years we spent trying to make everyone else happy.

And instead of seeing those decisions in context, we use them as evidence against ourselves.

Your Past Self Was Working With the Tools They Had

You were not making your past decisions with the nervous system, awareness, skills, and tools you have today.

You were making them with what was available to you then.

Your behavior may have been shaped by childhood survival strategies, attachment patterns, family dynamics, socialization, conditioning, and the nervous system responses you learned early in life.

Maybe saying yes kept you connected.

Maybe anticipating everyone’s needs helped you feel safe.

Maybe perfectionism earned you praise.

Maybe staying quiet reduced conflict.

Maybe abandoning your own needs helped you maintain belonging.

These patterns can become automatic. They run in the background without us consciously choosing them.

So of course you did what you did.

Of course you said yes when you wanted to say no.

Of course you dated the emotionally unavailable person or were emotionally unavailable yourself.

Of course you repeated patterns you had not yet learned how to interrupt.

Your past self was being the version of you they were neurologically capable of being at that moment.

Shame Does Not Create Sustainable Change

When we judge our past self, we often believe we are holding ourselves accountable.

But judgment and accountability are not the same thing.

Judgment can quickly become shame.

Shame tells us there is something inherently wrong with us. Instead of thinking, “I made a choice I would not make today,” we begin thinking, “I am the kind of person who makes terrible choices.”

That distinction matters.

Because when you turn a behavior into an identity, change can start to feel impossible.

If this is simply who I am, why would anything ever be different?

This is one reason we do not need to turn codependent, perfectionist, or people-pleasing patterns into permanent identities.

They are learned patterns.

And learned patterns can change.

Your Past Behavior Is Not Your Permanent Identity

There is a beautiful distinction in Spanish that can help us understand this.

Spanish has two verbs that translate to “to be”: ser and estar.

Very simply, ser can describe something more inherent or enduring, while estar describes states that can change.

We can apply this idea when thinking about our past self.

Instead of seeing past behavior as evidence of who you permanently are, you can see it as how you were being at that moment.

You were behaving from the skills you had.

You were responding from the nervous system you had.

You were making decisions from the information available to you.

That does not mean you have to like every choice you made.

It means you stop turning those choices into a life sentence.

Self-Acceptance Does Not Mean You Approve of Everything You Did

This is where people can get nervous.

If I stop judging myself, won’t I just make the same mistake again?

If I forgive my past self, am I saying what happened was okay?

No.

Acceptance is not approval.

You can say:

I accept that I made that decision. I understand why I made it. I do not want to make that decision again.

All three things can be true.

You can acknowledge harm.

You can take responsibility.

You can make amends when appropriate.

You can decide to behave differently going forward.

None of that requires cruelty.

In fact, compassion can make it easier to look honestly at what happened because you are no longer using reflection as an opportunity to attack yourself.

Your Nervous System Cannot Grow Through Constant Self-Attack

There is also a nervous system component to how you relate to your past self.

When you revisit your history through criticism and cruelty, your body may move into sympathetic activation, the mobilized fight or flight state.

You become anxious, activated, worried, and consumed with everything you did wrong.

Or you may move toward a dorsal state, feeling checked out, disconnected, hopeless, or frozen.

Neither state creates particularly fertile ground for thoughtful change.

Sustainable change is more available when we can approach ourselves from greater groundedness and safety.

This is why self-acceptance matters.

When you can look at your past without immediately launching into an internal attack, you create more space to ask useful questions.

What happened?

What was I trying to protect?

What did I believe at the time?

What would I like to do differently now?

Those questions move you forward.

Shame keeps you spinning backward.

Stop Treating Your Past Self Like They Had Today’s Information

One of the most unfair things we do is judge yesterday’s decisions using today’s knowledge.

You know what you know now because you lived through what happened then.

Every experience changed you.

Every relationship taught you something.

Every mistake gave you information.

Every moment of growth altered what became possible next.

Your life is like a moving river. You cannot step into exactly the same river twice because the water continues moving.

You are moving too.

The person looking back today is not the exact person who made that decision years ago.

So when you ask, “How could I have done that?” remember that you are asking the question from a completely different vantage point.

You know more now.

That is growth, not evidence that your past self was defective.

You Do Not Know What Your Past Choices Will Create

There is another reason to loosen our grip on judgment.

We do not know what growth may eventually come from a decision we currently regret.

That does not mean we need to romanticize painful experiences or pretend everything happens for a reason.

It means acknowledging that we cannot know every future consequence of our past.

A choice you wish you had made differently may eventually lead you toward an insight, relationship, boundary, or transformation you cannot yet see.

When we declare a past decision entirely terrible, we can slip back into the fantasy that we should have been able to predict and control everything.

But we cannot control the uncontrollable.

Growth asks us to make the next right choice with the information available to us now.

Beating Up Your Past Self Can Be a Distraction

Sometimes self-criticism can even prevent us from feeling what actually needs to be felt.

You might believe that repeatedly telling yourself how stupid you were means you are processing what happened.

But beating yourself up can become a way of avoiding the emotions underneath.

Grief.

Anger.

Guilt.

Disappointment.

Frustration.

Sadness.

Instead of allowing those feelings to move through the body, you stay busy prosecuting yourself.

Self-criticism gives the mind a job.

But it may keep you from doing the deeper work.

Compassion Makes Accountability Possible

Being compassionate toward your past self does not mean abandoning personal responsibility.

It can actually help you practice responsibility more effectively.

You can say:

I recognize that I made this choice.

I understand the patterns that contributed to it.

I recognize the impact it had.

I do not want to repeat it.

I am choosing to respond differently now.

This is compassionate, embodied self-responsibility.

You are neither denying what happened nor making yourself morally defective because it happened.

You are looking directly at your behavior and deciding what comes next.

You Were Doing the Best You Could Then

Your past self was working with the skills, tools, nervous system capacity, socialization, conditioning, and awareness they had at that moment.

That does not mean every choice was good.

It does not mean every behavior was harmless.

It means that version of you could not use tools they had not yet developed.

You know more now.

You have more awareness now.

Maybe you have more nervous system capacity now.

That means you can make different choices now.

This is the opportunity.

Not to go backward and punish the person who did not yet know what you know today.

To become the person who knows differently and acts differently.

A Practice for Relating Differently to Your Past Self

Think of one decision from your past that you regularly criticize yourself for.

Notice the language you use when you think about that version of yourself.

Maybe you call yourself stupid, weak, pathetic, naive, ridiculous, or foolish.

Pause.

Notice what happens in your body when you speak to yourself that way.

Then try approaching the same memory with curiosity.

Ask:

What did I believe at the time?

What was my nervous system trying to protect?

What skills did I not yet have?

What do I understand now that I did not understand then?

What can I choose differently because of what I know today?

The goal is not to rewrite history.

It is to change your relationship with it.

The Goal Is Not to Love Every Past Decision

You do not have to love everything your past self did.

You do not have to pretend painful choices were secretly wonderful.

You do not have to erase consequences or bypass accountability.

You can simply stop using those choices as weapons against yourself.

Your past is a fact.

You cannot change what happened.

But you can change how you relate to the person who lived through it.

And that relationship matters because your past self is still part of you.

Rejecting them means trying to grow while simultaneously rejecting part of the person doing the growing.

Final Thoughts

If you want to create meaningful change, stop asking shame to do the job of self-awareness.

Your past self did not have the knowledge, tools, or nervous system capacity you have today.

That version of you made choices from the programming, experiences, socialization, and survival strategies available at the time.

You can acknowledge those choices.

You can take responsibility for them.

You can learn from them.

And you can decide that you will do things differently now.

But you do not need to hate your past self to become someone new.

In fact, compassion, curiosity, self-acceptance, and embodied responsibility may be what finally allow you to move forward.

You are not the same person you were then.

So stop demanding that your past self should have somehow already been the person you are becoming now.

Want to Go Deeper?

Grab your copy of End Emotional Outsourcing to learn how to stop performing safety and start actually feeling it.

You will get real tools, somatic practices, and feminist coaching support to help you come home to yourself, one nervous-system-loving step at a time.

And if you want my free orienting audio and grounding meditations to support your daily practice, head here to get your free downloads.

My 12-week programs include live teaching, guided somatic practices, journaling workbooks, and a private podcast where I answer your questions directly. Learn more here.

Get on the waitlist for the next Anchored cohort here.